Can Ontario Doctors Speak Out? The Legal and Professional Framework

In November 2017, the Ontario Medical Association circulated a draft Code of Conduct to its 34,000 members. The Toronto Star noticed. Critics read it as an attempt to restrict what physicians could say publicly about the healthcare system, and about the OMA itself. Within months, the phrase “muzzle doctors” was appearing in CBC coverage.

That was the beginning of a multi-year dispute. It didn’t end in 2019. COVID-19 extended it in ways that nobody had anticipated.

Empty wood-panelled tribunal hearing room

The Numbers Behind the Dispute

21

Physicians disciplined by the CPSO for COVID-related conduct as of January 16, 2024. Five signed “never reapply” undertakings. Source: Wikipedia / CPSO public register.

40+

Physicians under active CPSO investigation for COVID-related conduct as of January 2022. Source: Global News, January 20, 2022.

718

Physicians who signed the “Declaration of Canadian Physicians for Science and Truth” by August 2022, in direct response to the CPSO’s April 2021 misinformation statement. Source: Wikipedia/CPSO.

$54M

Approximate annual mandatory OMA membership dues collected from Ontario physicians by law, as cited by advocacy groups and reported in CBC News coverage.


The CPSO’s Rules on Physician Public Expression

Physician free speech in Canada is not an absolute right. It is shaped by professional obligations that sit alongside, and sometimes in tension with, constitutional protections. The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario, the regulatory body that licenses every doctor in the province, has a formal Social Media policy, last updated in 2024. It does not prohibit public advocacy. It says explicitly that advocacy for patients and the healthcare system is “an important component of the physician’s role.”

The restrictions are specific, not sweeping. Under the policy, a physician communicating on social media must:

  • Ensure health claims are verifiable and supported by available evidence
  • Not create the impression they are providing individual clinical advice
  • Maintain the same standard of professional conduct online as in person
  • Not make discriminatory or harassing statements

Constructive criticism offered in good faith to improve patient care or facilities is listed explicitly as conduct not likely to be considered unprofessional. That’s the policy on paper.

The CPSO’s Advice to the Profession adds one practical caution: physicians working in institutional settings may be subject to their employer’s own social media rules, separate from the CPSO’s. The two frameworks can conflict. When they do, the physician is in the middle.

The aim of this policy is not to silence important advocacy or shut down healthy debate occurring online, but rather to encourage respectful dialogue.

CPSO Social Media Consultation statement, Dialogue publication

The OMA Code of Conduct: What Critics Called an Attempt to Muzzle Doctors

In November 2017, the OMA drafted a Code of Conduct for its members. The Toronto Star reported on it in the context of cyberbullying concerns at the association. But some physicians read its provisions differently, as a mechanism to silence dissent from within.

COD’s position, reported by CBC, was that the OMA’s new Code would effectively muzzle doctors in Ontario, preventing them from speaking openly about governance and funding decisions. That specific phrase, muzzle doctors, appeared in a CBC article covering COD’s accusations about OMA accountability and financial practices. The OMA collected approximately $54 million in mandatory dues annually through government-enabled legislation and, critics argued, was not financially transparent to its members about how that money was spent.

The OMA disputed this framing. Its public position was that the Code of Conduct set basic civility standards for internal communications, not for external public speech. The OMA’s mandate, per its own statements, is to amplify physicians’ voices on policy issues. How well it did that between 2015 and 2019 is precisely what COD and allied groups disputed.

What is documented: in 2017, a loss-of-confidence motion passed the OMA Council by 55% — the first in the association’s history. COD and the Coalition of Ontario Doctors had campaigned actively for OMA reform in the years leading up to that vote. The Code of Conduct debate was one piece of a broader governance dispute, not an isolated event.

The OMA’s Current Position (2024)

The OMA’s current Code of Conduct policy (POL0049-08, updated September 2023) focuses on conduct within OMA structures. Its stated purpose is to maintain a respectful environment for OMA activities. The policy does not purport to govern what physicians say to the public or to government. Whether its earlier draft versions went further is what critics contended in 2017–18, and the OMA has not publicly confirmed or denied the specific accusations made by COD and reported by CBC.


Open Letters as a Documented Advocacy Tool

Open letters are a specific form of physician advocacy that bypasses institutional channels entirely. They are addressed to politicians or regulators, signed by physicians, and published publicly. The legal risk is low, and public advocacy is a protected expression. The professional risk depends on content: letters that allege specific misconduct by named individuals, or that contain claims unsupported by evidence, have triggered complaints.

Two Ontario examples are documented on the public record. In April 2020, COD published an open letter from Ontario doctors directly to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Premier Doug Ford on COVID-19 preparedness and PPE shortages. The letter called on both governments to be transparent, to protect frontline workers, and to safeguard civil liberties. It was covered by news outlets and is archived.

Earlier in the group’s history, COD had run a petition campaign explicitly framed as a call to protect healthcare in Ontario, asking patients and physicians alike to pressure government on physician funding and OMA accountability.

These letters don’t operate in a vacuum. Their effectiveness depends entirely on media coverage, political timing, and whether they say something a news outlet can build a story around. The April 2020 PPE letter landed when PPE shortages were front-page news. The timing mattered more than the letter itself.


COVID-19 and Physician Dissent: What Happened in Ontario

April 30, 2021, is the date to know. That’s when the CPSO issued a formal statement on “Public Health Misinformation,” accusing unnamed Ontario doctors of using social media to undermine public health measures. The statement was explicit: physicians who did so could face investigation and discipline.

718 Canadian physicians, not just Ontario doctors, responded by signing a counter-declaration, the “Declaration of Canadian Physicians for Science and Truth.” They called the CPSO’s statement “unethical, anti-science and deeply disturbing.” Both documents are on the public record.

What followed was a five-year enforcement process. By January 2022, more than 40 Ontario physicians were under active investigation for COVID-related conduct. Seven had been handed licence suspensions or restrictions at that point. By January 2024, 21 had been formally disciplined. Five signed “never reapply” undertaking, meaning permanent loss of the ability to regain an Ontario medical licence.

Dr. Patrick Phillips, an emergency room physician in Englehart, Ontario, is the most reported case. The CPSO suspended his licence in May 2022. The allegations cited in the CPSO’s notice of hearing went beyond speech: they included inappropriate prescribing, issuing fraudulent vaccine exemptions, and workplace conduct. CBC News reported on the suspension at the time. Phillips had approximately 40,000 Twitter followers before his account was suspended.

Two things are true at once. The CPSO’s April 2021 statement said physicians could not publicly question COVID policies. And at least some of the subsequent disciplinary cases involved conduct that went well beyond speech — clinical decisions, prescription records, exemption documents. The public record does not always let you separate the two cleanly.

What the CPSO Said It Needed

In a letter to then-Health Minister Christine Elliott, CPSO Registrar Nancy Whitmore wrote that the college had been requesting legislative changes from the Ministry of Health since March 2019, and again in June 2021, to help it address physician complaints more efficiently. The Ministry had not responded to those requests. By 2023, the CPSO had 50 active cases in Ontario alone against 30 physicians for allegedly spreading COVID misinformation, with only two resolved in three years. The legislative framework, not the college’s willingness to act, was the stated bottleneck. Source: Global News, January 2022 and January 2023.


How Other Provinces Approached the Same Tension

Ontario was not unique. Alberta’s College of Physicians and Surgeons updated its Social Media Advice to the Profession in July 2024. The document takes a similar line to the CPSO — advocacy is legitimate, but claims must be evidence-based and physicians must not create confusion between public commentary and clinical advice. Alberta went further in enforcement during COVID: the CPSA conducted unannounced inspections of medical clinics where complaints had been filed, something the CPSO told Ontario’s government it could not legally do without legislative change.

British Columbia’s college declined to publicly disclose how many COVID-related complaints it received, per Global News’s January 2022 investigation. That investigation found doctors in both BC and Ontario sharing unverified information on side effects and issuing fraudulent exemptions.

The underlying tension between a regulator’s duty to protect public trust and an individual physician’s freedom to dissent from official guidance is not resolved anywhere in Canada. It is managed, not settled.


Sources and Official References

SourceWhat it covers
CPSO Social Media PolicyFull policy text on physician obligations when using social media, including advocacy provisions.
CPSO — cpso.on.caDiscipline tribunal hearings, public register, and disciplinary outcomes.
OMA — oma.orgOMA Code of Conduct policy (POL0049-08), member communications, and physician services agreement updates.
CBC News / Global News archivesContemporary reporting cited inline: CBC (April 2016, 2018, 2022), Global News (December 2018, January 2022, January 2023).