The 2016 OMA Physician Contract Referendum: Why Ontario Doctors Voted “No”
August 14, 2016. The last time the Ontario Medical Association had convened a full membership meeting was sometime in the 1980s, so far back that they rented Maple Leaf Gardens for it. That context matters. When thousands of Ontario physicians gathered to vote on a tentative agreement their own leadership had endorsed, it was not a routine procedural event. It was, as The Globe and Mail put it afterward, the beginning of a new era of physician militancy.
No Ontario doctor contract referendum had drawn member participation at this scale in decades.

Key Numbers from the 2016 Vote and Its Aftermath
63.1%
Physicians who voted “No” on August 14–15, 2016. 55% voter turnout. Source: OMA statement, CTV News, CBC News, August 15–16, 2016.
$11.5B
Annual Ontario physician services budget in 2016. The tentative deal offered 2.5% annual increases, growing it to $12.9 billion by 2020. Source: CBC News / CTV News, July–August 2016.
65%
OMA members who ratified the binding arbitration framework in June 2017 – the direct successor agreement to the failed 2016 deal. Source: OMA press release, June 17, 2017.
3.5%+
Minimum increase in the physician services budget awarded by the arbitration panel in February 2019, retroactive to April 1, 2017. Source: The Globe and Mail, February 2019.
Ontario Physicians Without a Contract: 2014 to 2016
The physicians’ contract had expired on March 31, 2014. For two years, the OMA and the Ministry of Health negotiated without reaching a deal. During that time, the Liberal government under Kathleen Wynne imposed two unilateral physician fee cuts: 2.65 percent in February 2015 and a further 1.3 percent in October 2015. Both were applied without an agreement in place.
Ontario was an outlier. Seven other provinces and the Northwest Territories set physician compensation through binding arbitration — a process that gives both sides access to an independent panel when talks stall. Ontario physicians had been requesting the same mechanism for years. The government refused.
By July 2016, the accumulated frustration had produced a profession that was, as CBC News described it in an August 2016 analysis, heading into “uncharted territory.” The OMA’s leadership had quietly negotiated a deal. Their members found out about it from the newspapers.
The offer seemingly came out of nowhere, negotiated quietly in backrooms after more than a year of no official talks.
The Globe and Mail, August 16, 2016
The July 2016 Tentative Agreement: What Was on the Table
Announced July 11, 2016, the OMA tentative agreement vote was the culmination of a four-year Physician Services Agreement endorsed by the OMA Board of Directors. OMA President Dr. Virginia Walley urged members to support it.
The core terms, as reported by CTV News and CBC News at the time:
- Annual increase of 2.5% to the total physician services budget, growing from $11.5 billion to approximately $12.9 billion by 2020.
- One-time supplementary payments in each of the four years: $50 million, $100 million, $120 million, and $100 million — subject to clawback if total billings exceeded the budget.
- A commitment that the government would not impose further “unilateral” fee cuts over the four years.
- A joint OMA–Ministry process to “identify savings” in physician services spending.
- No provision for binding arbitration.
The OMA framed the no-arbitration decision as a concession it had been forced to make. The government refused to include it, and the OMA argued that a partial deal offering “stability” was better than continued unilateral action. Health Minister Eric Hoskins said the deal gave physicians “a seat at the table where decisions are made about spending.” Critics called that framing optimistic at best.
Why Physicians Who Urged Colleagues to Vote “No” Argued Against the Deal
The campaign to vote “No” was led by the Coalition of Ontario Doctors, which included Concerned Ontario Doctors, DoctorsOntario, and nine OMA sections covering cardiology, emergency medicine, diagnostic imaging, gastroenterology, and others. The coalition’s August 15 statement called the PSA “vague, cut funding, and threatened our independence.”
Several specific objections circulated during the campaign weeks between July 11 and the vote:
- The 2.5% annual increase was, at best, enough to cover inflation and population growth. After years of cuts, it offered no restoration of lost ground.
- The “jointly identify savings” clause was read by high-billing specialties as a direct threat. Radiologists, ophthalmologists, and anesthesiologists, whose fees reflected procedures that had become faster with technology, believed they would be the primary target. The Globe and Mail reported this explicitly in its August 2016 analysis. It turned out to be an accurate read.
- The clawback provisions meant the stated 2.5% was not guaranteed. If collective billings exceeded the budget cap, the supplementary payments would be reduced.
- No binding arbitration. This was the central structural objection. Without it, the cycle of unilateral government action could restart the moment the deal expired.
- The deal had been negotiated without informing OMA section chairs. A resolution demanding full section-chair involvement in future negotiations passed alongside the main vote.
The OMA had originally planned a non-binding referendum, with the 275-member OMA Council making the final ratification call. COD and allied groups objected. They argued members deserved a direct binding vote. The OMA cancelled the original referendum and convened the full membership meeting instead — the first time that had happened since the 1980s.
What the “Yes” Campaign Argued
OMA President Dr. Virginia Walley and the Board held that the deal, while imperfect, offered something the status quo did not: a formal guarantee against further unilateral cuts for four years. The government had imposed cuts twice without an agreement in 2015. Another round was a realistic possibility. The OMA’s pitch was essentially: “Hold your nose and vote yes — it’s better than more unilateral cuts.” That framing did not carry the room.
After the “No” Vote: What Happened Next
| Aug 2016 | 63.1% of voting OMA members reject the tentative PSA. OMA described as being “in crisis” by CBC. Health Minister Hoskins expresses disappointment. Patrick Brown (PC Leader) calls the negotiation process “irretrievably flawed.” |
| Sep–Oct 2016 | OMA Board and executive members who endorsed the deal face member anger. Calls for board resignations at the membership meeting. The OMA announces it wants to return to negotiations immediately. |
| Nov 2016 | OMA President Dr. Virginia Walley and five other executive members resign. The Globe and Mail reports the No vote “touched off months of turmoil within the OMA.” New president Dr. Shawn Whatley, a small-town family doctor, is elected. |
| Jan 2017 | OMA Council passes a historic loss-of-confidence motion against its own executive. The 55% vote is the first such motion in OMA history. Advocacy groups including COD had campaigned for OMA reform. |
| May 2017 | OMA and the Wynne Liberal government reach a tentative binding arbitration framework. The framework agreement explicitly states that neither side nor any arbitrator can rely on the terms of the rejected 2016 deal. The Globe and Mail notes that cutting the 2016 PSA loose is a precondition for moving forward. |
| Jun 2017 | Members ratify the binding arbitration framework 65% to 35%. Seven other provinces already had this mechanism. For Ontario physicians, it ends three years of “unprecedented fee cuts and unilateral government action” — in the words of new OMA president Dr. Whatley. |
| Dec 2018 | Ford government attempts to withdraw from arbitration, dismissing its own arbitration board appointee. Reason given: “public dispute” within the profession, as a specialist group tries to break away from the OMA. OMA denounces the move as an “affront to the rule of law.” |
| Dec 2018 | Government reverses course within days. Arbitration resumes. Within 48 hours, the province’s arbitration appointee is reinstated. The process continues. |
| Feb 2019 | Arbitration panel issues its award. Minimum 3.5% increase over four years, retroactive to April 1, 2017. The panel rejects the government’s request for a hard budget cap. Health Minister Christine Elliott commits to respecting the award. |
The 2016 Vote’s Lasting Effects on Ontario Health Policy
Three things changed because of the No vote, and they did not change quickly.
First: binding arbitration. The single most important structural demand of the Vote No campaign, the one the OMA had abandoned in negotiating the 2016 deal, was achieved within thirteen months of the vote’s outcome. That was not coincidental. The strength of the No vote made clear to the government that physicians would not accept another agreement without it.
Second: OMA governance reform. The membership meeting in August 2016 and the subsequent executive resignations reset the OMA’s internal politics. Advocacy groups, including COD, had been calling for financial transparency and democratic reform within the OMA since at least 2015. The 2016 vote accelerated those conversations. A loss-of-confidence motion passed the OMA Council in January 2017. New leadership took the organization in a different direction.
Third: the precedent of a direct membership vote. The OMA had originally planned to let its 275-member Council ratify the 2016 deal after a non-binding member poll. Physician groups forced a full membership vote instead. That mechanism, the general meeting of members with a binding vote, has not been used since. But the 2016 event demonstrated that members could demand and receive direct democratic participation in major decisions.
Whether the February 2019 arbitration award adequately restored what physicians lost between 2015 and 2019 is a separate question. The OMA’s president at the time acknowledged that “many good doctors” had made difficult decisions, closed practices, retired early, or left the province during those years. The FAO’s 2025 data shows the per-capita physician ratio in Ontario fell between 2018–19 and 2023–24. Physician compensation in Ontario remains a live issue. The OMA and Ministry have continued to negotiate under the 2017 binding arbitration framework, with the most recent agreement expiring in March 2024.
Sources
| Source | What it covers |
|---|---|
| CBC News — August 16, 2016 | Vote result, OMA president’s response, Health Minister Hoskins statement. Vote percentage and turnout. |
| CTV News — August 15, 2016 | Vote result, OMA statement, Patrick Brown (PC) response. Agreement terms: $11.5B budget, 2.5% annual increase. |
| The Globe and Mail — August 16, 2016 | Analysis: “Ontario doctors vote to get tough at the bargaining table.” Context on OMA’s handling of the deal, radiologist–ophthalmologist concerns, calls for arbitration. |
| OMA Press Release — June 17, 2017 | Binding arbitration framework ratification result: 65% to 35%. OMA president Dr. Shawn Whatley statement. |
| The Globe and Mail — February 2019 | Arbitration award: 3.5%+ over four years, retroactive to April 1, 2017. Hard cap rejected. OMA president Dr. Nadia Alam statement. |
